Is reducing energy consumption important for climate change?
publiziert: Freitag, 12. Feb 2016 / 14:27 Uhr

It is natural to think that reducing our energy consumption is good for the climate. We can ride a bicycle instead of driving a car. And if we drive a car, we can drive a smaller, more fuel-efficient car. These things certainly help reduce urban noise, congestion, and air pollution. But do they really help to solve climate change?

World leaders in Paris renewed their pledge to limit climate change to no more than 2°C warming. The science backs this up, and suggests that even with 2°C warming, there may be some catastrophic consequences. The science is also clear that to achieve the 2°C limit, and certainly any limit even more ambitious, like 1.5°C, we need to completely eliminate carbon dioxide (CO2) emissions in the energy sector as quickly as possible.

A necessary and sufficient condition

There is an equation, known as the Kaya Identity, which can help us think about this problem. It states that our CO2 emissions are equal to the product of our population, each person's consumption, the energy intensity of that consumption, and the carbon intensity of that energy. Mathematically it looks like this:

Any schoolchild can tell you that if the left-hand side of this equation is going to be zero, then one of the terms on the right-hand side of the equation must be zero as well. Moreover, if one of those terms is zero, then it doesn't matter what the other terms are: zero times anything else always equals zero. And it is also clear which of those terms it has to be. Most of us do not want to live in a world with no people, no consumption, or no energy use! But most of us would be happy to live in a world where all of our energy comes from carbon-neutral sources, as long as that energy is affordable, reliable, and environmentally sustainable. So reducing the carbon intensity of energy to zero, quickly, is the necessary and sufficient step to solving climate change.

Do sufficiency and efficiency help?

Does reducing our level of consumption or improving energy efficiency help to speed up the pace with which we completely decarbonize the energy system? The answer depends on a lot of other choices that we make.
Imagine, for example, a scenario where Switzerland decides that it does not want to import any energy. (Right now we import roughly three quarters of our primary energy supply as oil, uranium, natural gas, and coal). In all likelihood, the main sources of energy would then have to be hydropower, photovoltaic panels, and biomass. Given the environmental limits on hydropower and biomass production, we would need to devote a large area to photovoltaic panels: not only every available rooftop, but also some of our current agricultural land. However, if we reduced energy consumption, we could eliminate the need for this land and so avoid the local battles associated with converting farmers? fields to solar fields. And that would probably make the transition away from imported fossil fuel easier.

It depends ...

But imagine that the Swiss people continue to import energy, such as from wind farms on the Atlantic coast or solar farms around the Mediterranean. In fact there is more of this energy available, especially solar energy, than we will ever use. At the same time, how we use energy can determine how attractive renewable sources are, compared to fossil fuels. Both hydropower and solar energy, for example, are more plentiful and hence less expensive during the summer. If you live in a home with air conditioning, your energy demand is highest in the summer, and switching from fossil power to renewable power could be especially attractive. By contrast a household without air conditioning, consuming mostly in winter when hydropower and solar are scarce, would have a lower incentive to switch.

Similarly, electric cars are less expensive to own than combustion engine cars, as long as you drive them more than about 10,000 km per year. Below that, the highly efficient electric drive train simply isn't worth the larger up-front investment. Of course, driving huge amounts in any car is bad for our communities and for the environment. But it is better to drive 11'000 km in an electric car than 9'000 km in a combustion one. There have not been any scientific studies on this, but one can easily imagine that a mobility policy focused on helping car owners to drive less could in fact delay the transition to electric vehicles.

De-carbonization is key

There are many ways to reduce our energy demand through lifestyle choices and improved efficiency, with broad environmental and social benefits. But we should not fool ourselves into thinking that by doing these things, and these things alone, we necessarily help to solve climate change. We can only solve climate change by replacing fossil fuels with other sources of energy.

The good news is that these other energy sources exist, and are already beginning to compete with fossil fuels on an even footing. Our energy consumption choices can help to accelerate their adoption. Every switch from oil to electricity, whether in mobility or home heating, matters. Some of those choices may involve using less energy, but others may involve using more. To stop climate change it is far more important where our energy comes from than simply how much of it we use.

(Prof. Anthony Patt/ETH-Zukunftsblog)

Digitaler Strukturwandel  Nach über 16 Jahren hat sich entschlossen, den Titel in seiner jetzigen Form einzustellen. Damit endet eine Ära medialer Pionierarbeit. mehr lesen 21
Mit Biogas betriebene Wärme-Kraft-Kopplungsanlagen (WKK) können fluktuierenden Solarstrom kompensieren und Gebäude beheizen.
Mit Biogas betriebene ...
Eine zentrale Herausforderung der Energiewende ist es, die schwankende Stromproduktion aus erneuerbaren Quellen auszugleichen. Eine Machbarkeitsstudie zeigt nun für drei Schweizer Kantone auf, wie ein Verbund von Wärme-Kraft-Kopplungsanlagen kurzfristige Engpässe überbrücken und Gebäude mit Strom und Wärme versorgen kann. mehr lesen 
Vor rund hundert Jahren begann die Industrialisierung der Landwirtschaft - heute erleben wir den Beginn ihrer Digitalisierung. Damit die Big-Data-Welle den Bauer ... mehr lesen  
Vor rund hundert Jahren begann die Industrialisierung der Landwirtschaft - heute erleben wir den Beginn ihrer Digitalisierung.
Wie werden Wasserkraftwerke wieder rentabel?
Die Schweizer Wasserkraft darbt. Die Ursache dafür sind letztlich Verzerrungen im europäischen Strommarkt. Nun diskutiert die Politik Subventionen für die ... mehr lesen  
Climate change has been communicated as a global concern affecting all of mankind; but this message doesn't seem to be getting through. If ... mehr lesen  
Climate change has been communicated as a global concern affecting all of mankind; but this message doesn't seem to be getting through.

Fakten und Meinungen zu Nachhaltigkeit

Der Zukunftsblog der ETH Zürich nimmt aktuelle Themen der Nachhaltigkeit auf. Er bietet eine Informations- und Meinungsplattform, auf der sich Expertinnen und Experten der ETH zu den Themenschwerpunkten Klimawandel, Energie, Zukunftsstädte, Welternährung und Natürliche Ressourcen äussern. Prominente Gäste aus Forschung, Politik und Gesellschaft tragen mit eigenen Beiträgen zur Diskussion bei.

Lesen Sie weitere Beiträge und diskutieren Sie mit auf:

Green Investment geht in Klausur Nach über 16 Jahren hat sich entschlossen, den Titel in ... 21
Wunschkredit in CHF
Heute So Mo
Zürich 15°C 21°C Wolkenfelder, kaum Regenleicht bewölkt, ueberwiegend sonnig freundlich recht sonnig
Basel 15°C 23°C recht sonnigleicht bewölkt, ueberwiegend sonnig recht sonnig recht sonnig
St. Gallen 13°C 19°C viele Gewitterleicht bewölkt, ueberwiegend sonnig recht sonnig recht sonnig
Bern 15°C 20°C Wolkenfelder, kaum Regenleicht bewölkt, ueberwiegend sonnig recht sonnig sonnig
Luzern 15°C 20°C Wolkenfelder, kaum Regenleicht bewölkt, ueberwiegend sonnig recht sonnig recht sonnig
Genf 14°C 22°C freundlichleicht bewölkt, ueberwiegend sonnig recht sonnig sonnig
Lugano 20°C 29°C freundlichleicht bewölkt, ueberwiegend sonnig sonnig sonnig
mehr Wetter von über 8 Millionen Orten