Recover the many benefits
Reforestation: a chance for farmers
publiziert: Mittwoch, 11. Jun 2014 / 12:30 Uhr

Europe's forests are recent secondary regrowth from a period when, little more than 100 years ago, they had been all but eradicated from the landscape. Now, we seek to restore forests to recover the many benefits they provide. Can we hope for the same transition in the tropics, where deforestation remains rampant?

1 Meldung im Zusammenhang
The European transition from a long history of deforestation to a recent history of reforestation was facilitated by a shift from a predominantly agricultural economy to one supported by manufacturing and services. This transition may raise optimism for the future of forests in the tropics, where large areas of primary forest still fall prey to deforestation to make way for cattle, soy or oil palm.

Is such optimism justified? I believe it is, as there are already indications of a gradual transition to reforestation. Since the 1990s forests have expanded in Bhutan, China, Costa Rica, Cuba, El Salvador, Gambia, India, Puerto Rico, Vietnam and in certain parts of Brazil. This change is resulting, at least in part, from the abandonment of marginal lands by small-scale farmers who cannot compete with large intensive agricultural enterprises. Rural depopulation has many undesirable social implications, including the collapse of rural communities and the crowding of urban centres. Nonetheless, the recovery of forests has the potential to provide many ecosystem service benefits, from soaking up carbon and maintaining rainfall, to protecting water flows and reducing soil degradation and protecting us from natural hazards. Even so, this process raises three difficult questions.

 1. How much forest will be lost in the tropics before the transition to reforestation is initiated? A lot, if the European experience is anything to go by. Forest cover in the Scotland dropped to 5%, and to 14% in France and Switzerland, before recovering to 18% in Scotland, and around 30% in France and Switzerland. Losses of this magnitude in the tropics will spell disaster for biodiversity and the richness of forest goods.

2. What kind of forest will we end up with? Regenerating forests tend to be poorer in species, in ecosystem service functions, and in their ability to resist disturbances. They also tend to be less heterogeneous - in other words, duller.

3. What happens to the former farmers? Former farmers might find employment in cities, or on large agricultural estates or mining enterprises. Or they might struggle to find employment at all.

From farmers to foresters

We could solve these problems by some forward thinking and a little bit of money. Let me propose that we pay farmers to retain trees on their lands, to reforest land no longer economically viable for crops, and to pay them for the ecosystem services their forests provide. By paying farmers to conserve and reforest we could avoid deep forest cover losses, we could enhance the quality of recovering forest, and we could keep people on the land.

This is not, of course, a new proposal. Payments for ecosystem services (PES) are well established and widespread. In Tanzania, for example, a government PES scheme facilitated the restoration of 350'000 ha of Miombo woodland through support of people from over 800 villages. In northwest Vietnam PES have motivated several villages to conserve and restore natural forests by planting native trees, resulting in the recovery of water flow to rice fields and the return of over 30 rare mammals to the region. Deforestation has been slowed or halted, rich forests and diverse ecosystem services have been restored, biodiversity is back. What's more, villagers have a new found confidence to manage their own lands, and resist external pressures to deforest. Their livelihoods are secure, so long as payments for the services they deliver keep flowing. They are, moreover, still occupiers of their land. Should food demands rise, these farmer-foresters can readily return to cash crops should they so choose.

So, where agricultural production is no longer economically viable, we should offer farmers the option of becoming foresters. There is one fly in the ointment - we need to be prepared to pay. If we are not, then are we really in a position to decry the loss of forests, the degradation of ecosystem services, and the extinction of species?

(Prof. Jaboury Ghazoul/ETH-Zukunftsblog)

Lesen Sie hier mehr zum Thema
ETH-Zukunftsblog 2014 will be the International Year ... mehr lesen
Jaboury Ghazoul ist Professor für Ökosystem-Management an der ETH Zürich.
Digitaler Strukturwandel  Nach über 16 Jahren hat sich entschlossen, den Titel in seiner jetzigen Form einzustellen. Damit endet eine Ära medialer Pionierarbeit. mehr lesen 21
Mit Biogas betriebene Wärme-Kraft-Kopplungsanlagen (WKK) können fluktuierenden Solarstrom kompensieren und Gebäude beheizen.
Mit Biogas betriebene ...
Eine zentrale Herausforderung der Energiewende ist es, die schwankende Stromproduktion aus erneuerbaren Quellen auszugleichen. Eine Machbarkeitsstudie zeigt nun für drei Schweizer Kantone auf, wie ein Verbund von Wärme-Kraft-Kopplungsanlagen kurzfristige Engpässe überbrücken und Gebäude mit Strom und Wärme versorgen kann. mehr lesen 
Vor rund hundert Jahren begann die Industrialisierung der Landwirtschaft - heute erleben wir den Beginn ihrer Digitalisierung. Damit die Big-Data-Welle den Bauer nicht vom Acker schwemmt, sondern ihn optimal unterstützt, gilt es, das Feld früh zu bestellen und Marken zu setzen, damit die digitale Landwirtschaft die richtigen Fragen adressiert. mehr lesen  
Die Schweizer Wasserkraft darbt. Die Ursache dafür sind letztlich Verzerrungen im europäischen Strommarkt. Nun diskutiert die Politik Subventionen für die ... mehr lesen  
Wie werden Wasserkraftwerke wieder rentabel?
Climate change has been communicated as a global concern affecting all of mankind; but this message doesn't seem to be getting through.
Climate change has been communicated as a global concern affecting all of mankind; but this message doesn't seem to be getting through. If indeed the human brain responds better to experience ... mehr lesen  

Fakten und Meinungen zu Nachhaltigkeit

Der Zukunftsblog der ETH Zürich nimmt aktuelle Themen der Nachhaltigkeit auf. Er bietet eine Informations- und Meinungsplattform, auf der sich Expertinnen und Experten der ETH zu den Themenschwerpunkten Klimawandel, Energie, Zukunftsstädte, Welternährung und Natürliche Ressourcen äussern. Prominente Gäste aus Forschung, Politik und Gesellschaft tragen mit eigenen Beiträgen zur Diskussion bei.

Lesen Sie weitere Beiträge und diskutieren Sie mit auf:

Green Investment geht in Klausur Nach über 16 Jahren hat sich entschlossen, den Titel in ... 21
Wunschkredit in CHF
Heute So Mo
Zürich 9°C 24°C recht sonnigleicht bewölkt, ueberwiegend sonnig wolkig, aber kaum Regen wechselnd bewölkt
Basel 11°C 26°C sonnigleicht bewölkt, ueberwiegend sonnig wechselnd bewölkt, Regen freundlich
St. Gallen 12°C 22°C sonnigleicht bewölkt, ueberwiegend sonnig vereinzelte Gewitter wolkig, aber kaum Regen
Bern 10°C 24°C sonnigleicht bewölkt, ueberwiegend sonnig wolkig, aber kaum Regen wechselnd bewölkt
Luzern 11°C 24°C sonnigleicht bewölkt, ueberwiegend sonnig gewitterhaft wechselnd bewölkt
Genf 12°C 24°C wolkig, aber kaum Regenleicht bewölkt, ueberwiegend sonnig wechselnd bewölkt, Regen freundlich
Lugano 16°C 23°C wechselnd bewölktleicht bewölkt, ueberwiegend sonnig trüb und nass freundlich
mehr Wetter von über 8 Millionen Orten